Clearest Video of Lightning-Generated 'Sprites' High Above Thunderstorms Captured
Researchers seek clues to mysterious flashes of light
Thursday, February 16, 2006
Durham, N.C. -- Researchers at Duke University’s Pratt School of Engineering
have captured the best images ever produced of "sprites" --
mysterious flashes of light resembling giant undulating jellyfish
that can occur above strong thunderstorms -- using a high-speed
camera that recorded thousands of video frames a second.
The researchers said their findings could lead to a better
understanding of the physics and chemistry of this fleeting,
still-unexplained lightning phenomenon. They recorded and analyzed
video of sprites associated with powerful thunderstorms occurring
over the Great Plains during the summer of 2005. Their findings are
scheduled to appear online in Geophysical Research Letters on Feb.
22. The research was supported by the National Science
Foundation.
“By analyzing the high-speed images in sequence, we’ve been able
to clearly define, for the first time, the processes by which
sprites develop and what happens inside of them,” said Steven
Cummer, assistant professor of electrical and computer
engineering at Duke’s Pratt School. “This understanding of sprite
structure is a necessary step to further elucidate sprite dynamics
and their possible effects on the upper atmosphere.”
Sprites are one of the most common of a number of so-called
mesospheric transient luminous events (TLEs) driven by lightning,
Cummer said. Other such lightning-related phenomena include blue
jets, elves and terrestrial gamma ray flashes.
Since sprites were discovered in 1989, scientists have been
attempting to measure and document them, Cummer said. The first
high-speed images of sprites were reported by other researchers in
1999. Shortly thereafter, a second group captured the first images
of sprites recorded at 1,000 frames per second.
“Each improvement has revealed important new information about
the processes involved and their possible larger scale impact on
the upper atmosphere,” Cummer said in an interview. “However, many
sprites develop too quickly to be fully resolved even at one
millisecond time resolution.”
Sprites typically last for 10 to 100 milliseconds -- shorter
than the blink of a human eye, which takes an average of 300 to 400
milliseconds. Their transience makes sprites difficult to see with
the naked eye, despite their common occurrence in association with
certain types of active thunderstorms, the researchers said.
The vantage point required for a good view also complicates
direct observation of sprites, said Nicolas Jaugey, a member of
Cummer’s team at the Pratt School. Sprites generally form between
20 and 50 miles above storms and can often be obscured by lower
lying thunderclouds. Therefore, it’s best to view them from a
mountaintop or other high point about 100 to 300 miles away from a
storm, he said.
The Pratt team -- along with collaborators Walter Lyons and
Thomas Nelson of FMA Research Inc. in Fort Collins, Colo. – set up
an intensified high-speed camera capable of recording more than
5,000 frames per second at the Yucca Ridge Field Station in Fort
Collins from July through August 2005. From that site, the
researchers could look out over the Great Plains to image storms
occurring over Kansas and Nebraska.
Night after night, the group watched the weather forecast for
conditions ripe for sprites, said Jaugey, who was in Fort Collins
for the duration of the research campaign. When a promising storm
was brewing, the researchers pointed the high- speed camera in the
right direction and watched events unfold remotely on a television
displaying video from a low-light camera.
“Sometimes we’d get lucky and there would be a sprite every 10
to 15 minutes,” Jaugey said. “Other times, we would wait for four
hours and only get two events.”
Although much of the time was spent waiting, the researchers had
to keep a very close watch in order to capture the sprites. The
events happen so fast that they would often occur in just one
normal speed video frame, Cummer said.
“They happen about as fast as you can possibly see anything on a
normal television,” he said.
“We had to watch for brief flashes and call them out when they
happened,” added Jaugey. This meant that the team had to be
particularly adept at differentiating flashes indicative of a
sprite from lightning itself.
When the proper type of flash was seen, one of the team members
pressed a button to start the high-speed camera recording. The
cameras record so much data so quickly that they can only be
activated when a suspected sprite occurs, they explained.
“When we knew a storm was good, it wasn’t a problem to wait,”
Jaugey said. “When a sprite is captured on film, it’s extremely
exciting. You see just a flash on the TV screen, but when you
retrieve the recording from the high-speed camera and see its
development, it’s very beautiful.”
Over the entire field season, the researchers captured 76 TLE
sequences on seven different nights, 66 of which contained
distinguishable sprite elements, they reported. As luck would have
it, they produced the best images on the night of Aug. 13 -- their
very last day in the field, the researchers said. It is those
images that the team analyzed in detail in the latest report.
Based on the observations, sprites normally begin almost 50
miles high as downward-moving “streamers” that appear spontaneously
or at the bottom of a halo -- diffuse flashes of light often
associated with sprites. The streamers then branch out as they move
down. At the same time, a brighter column of light expands both up
and down from the starting point, followed by bright streamers that
shoot higher into the sky.
The group’s videos also revealed new details of “isolated dots,”
bright spots of light -- first described by other investigators --
that often glow for longer than any other portion of the sprite.
The pictures show that some of these bright spots form when
individual streamers collide, presumably as a result of
electrostatic attraction between them, according to the
researchers.
The greater energy intensity found at those spots makes them
particularly important for understanding the impact of sprites on
atmospheric chemistry, Cummer said.
“Electrons with enough energy to produce light can also produce
interesting chemical species not normally generated,” Cummer said.
“Such chemicals might be long-lived and could be transported to
other locations through the atmosphere.” Because isolated dots
persist for the longest, they may be sites where a significant
portion of such chemical reactions occur.
The new insight into how these bright spots form could lead
other researchers to produce better models of their physics and
chemistry, he said. The Duke team will also conduct further
analyses to relate their sprite image sequences to information they
gathered on the lightning-produced magnetic and electric fields
that spawned them.
“We should be able to make new connections between the lightning
strength and speed required to produce these phenomena in the upper
atmosphere,” Cummer said.
Other collaborators on the study included Jingbo Li, of Duke, and Elizabeth Gerken, of SRI International in Menlo Park, Calif.



